The Essential Guide to Contacting College Baseball Programs: For Parents and Athletes Who Want to Get Recruited

The Essential Guide to Contacting College Baseball Programs: For Parents and Athletes Who Want to Get Recruited

As a successful baseball coach with years of experience, I’ve seen far too many talented athletes miss opportunities. Missed opportunities not because they lacked ability, but because they didn’t know how to take the right steps. This guide cuts through the noise and gives you the real-world strategies college coaches are actually looking for in communication from prospects and families.

🧭 Section 1: The Recruiting Reality Check

✔️ College Coaches Don't Discover – They Evaluate

  • Most college coaches don’t find players. Players make themselves known.

  • If you aren’t proactively reaching out, you’re likely invisible to 95% of programs.

✔️ You’re Competing With 1,000s of Other Players

  • Every coach gets hundreds of emails and messages. Make yours stand out.

  • Being good isn't enough. You have to be targeted, prepared, and professional.

✉️ Section 2: Step-by-Step How to Contact a College Baseball Program

Step 1: Create Your “Player Recruiting Profile Packet”

This is your version of a résumé, what coaches want to see at first glance.

Include the following in a one-page PDF:

  • Full Name, Graduation Year, School

  • Primary & Secondary Position(s)

  • Height, Weight, Bats/Throws

  • Verified Measurables (60 time, velo, pop time, exit velo – include how and when it was verified)

  • Academic Info (GPA, test scores, academic honors)

  • Summer Team / HS Coach Contact Info

  • Short Paragraph Summary (1–2 sentences) of who you are

  • Link to Highlight Video (2–4 minutes)

  • Social media or recruiting profile links

✅ Tip: Make this a link (Google Drive, Dropbox) that can be easily viewed without downloading.

Step 2: Build Your Target List of Schools (15–30)

Break them into 3 tiers:

  • Reach: Dream schools slightly above your level.

  • Fit: Schools that match your current academic and athletic standing.

  • Safety: Places you’re confident you could compete at and get accepted.

Research each school’s:

  • Roster (Do they need your position?)

  • Coaching staff names and emails

  • Recent recruiting classes

  • Style of play, program goals, geography, size, academics, and cost

✅ Tip: Don’t email the “info@” email—address your message to an actual coach.

Step 3: Write a Personal, Direct, and Impactful Email

Subject line: 2026 RHP – 6’2” – 88 MPH – 4.1 GPA – [Your Name]
(Coaches scan subject lines, get your info upfront.)

Body:

  • Address the coach by name

  • Explain why you're interested in their program specifically

  • Include 2–3 quick bullets: measurables, academics, current team

  • Mention your upcoming events/tournaments

  • Link to your profile + highlight video

  • Sign off with name and contact info

✅ Tip: Don’t copy-paste mass emails. Coaches can tell. Always personalize!

Step 4: Follow Up But Do It the Right Way

If you haven’t heard back in 10–14 days, follow up with:

  • A short email updating a new stat, achievement, or upcoming event.

  • A video clip of a recent great play.

✅ Tip: Coaches love to see growth over time, not just one perfect video.

📲 Section 3: Bonus Tips

🎥 Highlight Video Tips:

  • 2–4 minutes max.

  • Game footage AND a short skills session.

  • Lead with your best 2–3 plays.

  • No music. No fancy transitions. Just you performing.

💬 Communication Tips:

  • Players should write the emails, not parents.

  • Coaches want to hear from the athlete directly.

  • Parents: Be supportive and involved but stay in the background during communication.

📅 When to Start Contacting Schools:

  • Sophomore year: Build your packet and list, start researching.

  • Summer after sophomore year: Begin emailing coaches and attending events.

  • Junior year: Major outreach push and visits.

  • Senior year: Fine-tuning, committing, academic paperwork.

✅ Tip: Earlier isn’t always better. Coaches want to see growth, not just age.

🚨 Mistakes That Turn Coaches Off Immediately

  • Emails from parents pretending to be the player

  • Highlight videos with no context or irrelevant plays

  • No academic information

  • Generic “Dear Coach” or wrong school name

  • No contact info or bad links

  • Bad body language or poor social media presence

 

🎯 Parents & Athletes, Remember...

Getting recruited isn’t about who you know, it’s about who knows you and what they see when you show up. This guide isn’t theory. These steps reflect what actually works.

You don’t need to be perfect, you just need to be proactive, coachable, and authentic.

Back to blog